---
phase: 01-design-tokens-rams-foundation
verified: 2026-10-22T02:55:00Z
status: passed
score: 13/14 plan must-haves verified literally (14/14 at goal level); 4/4 roadmap success criteria verified
overrides_applied: 0
re_verification: # initial — no previous VERIFICATION.md existed
  previous_status: null
  previous_score: null
  gaps_closed: []
  gaps_remaining: []
  regressions: []
gaps: []
deferred:
  - truth: "Basemap POI icons come from the hosted colored OFM sprite (not token-derived)"
    addressed_in: "Phase 3 / Phase 5 (first product map phase)"
    evidence: "Logged in phase deferred-items.md #1; Phase 3 SC1 renders the live position on the Rams basemap, Phase 5 renders route display — treatment candidates (text-only POIs, custom grayscale sprite) attached to those map phases"
  - truth: "Sprite-pattern layers (landcover_wetland, road_area_pattern) left un-derived"
    addressed_in: "Phase 3 / Phase 5"
    evidence: "Logged in phase deferred-items.md #3; visible only at zooms above the proof view"
  - truth: "Self-hosted pbf glyph route for Rams map-label fonts (Space Grotesk/Geist as map glyphs)"
    addressed_in: "Candidate for Phase 2+ (Worker infra) / product map phases"
    evidence: "Recorded in liberty-rams.json metadata.rams-font-substitutions reason: 'revisit with a Worker-served glyphs route'; no Phase 1 SC requires self-hosted glyphs, and no later phase SC claims it — tracked here for visibility"
---

# Phase 1: Design Tokens + Rams Foundation — Verification Report

**Phase Goal:** The Telemetry Rams design system exists as one centralized, importable token set — including map basemap cartography — with a user-approved mockup-vs-implementation gallery proving the fidelity bar before any product screen is built.
**Verified:** 2026-10-22T02:55:00Z
**Status:** passed
**Re-verification:** No — initial verification

## Goal Achievement

### Observable Truths (roadmap success criteria = the contract)

| # | Truth (Roadmap SC) | Status | Evidence |
|---|--------------------|--------|----------|
| 1 | Every rendered Rams component derives exclusively from the centralized token set — audit sweep finds zero off-token values | ✓ VERIFIED | `npm run audit` re-run on freshly rebuilt dist: **AUDIT CLEAN — 354 declarations, 0 off-token values** (55 colors / 9 radius tokens all zero / 7 families / 6 spacing / 10 type sizes / 9 trackings). `border-radius` forms in dist: `0`, `var(--radius)`, `3.40282e38px` (sanctioned rounded-full clamp) — no `.25rem`. tokens.css is the audit allowlist source (`DEFAULT_TOKENS = src/tokens.css`). |
| 2 | Side-by-side gallery exists and is user-approved (DSGN-02 mechanism) | ✓ VERIFIED | `theme/gallery.html` (290 lines, CDN-free, token-driven): 4 mockup-vs-sheet rows + basemap row + token ledger (names only) + approval strip; `<img>` links to all 5 committed captures (visually inspected — real renders). `01-04-DSGN-02-APPROVAL.md` records verbatim user response **"approved"** (2026-10-22T00:51:39Z), scope = fidelity bar + basemap direction. |
| 3 | Rams-styled MapLibre basemap renders in a browser | ✓ VERIFIED | `theme/basemap/liberty-rams.json` (110 layers, `metadata.rams-cartography.derived-from = theme/src/tokens.css` with per-role derivation formulas) + `index.html` MapLibre proof page (loads `./liberty-rams.json`, route color read at runtime via `getComputedStyle('--color-signal-orange')`). Committed real-browser capture `screenshots/basemap-kl.png` inspected: grayscale/muted KL metro, muted labels, zero orange except the reserved route vector. |
| 4 | Design authority is singular (conflict resolved) | ✓ VERIFIED | Root `DESIGN.md` carries the SUPERSEDED-FOR-SPECIFICS banner (conflicting Helvetica/Inter typography + palette explicitly marked superseded, values delegated to the package). `README.md` contains zero hex/px. Mockup tree untouched (git porcelain clean — read-only per D-06, `@source` scoped to its markup only). One token package (`theme/`), all scripts delegate to it. |

**Score (goal level):** 4/4 success criteria verified

### Plan-Level Must-Haves (merged from PLAN frontmatters)

| Plan | Truth | Status | Evidence |
|------|-------|--------|----------|
| 01 | Tokens importable as plain CSS (`@theme static` + `:root`) | ✓ VERIFIED | tokens.css 176 lines; dist carries token vars |
| 01 | Build produces compiled dist with Tailwind v4 utilities | ✓ VERIFIED | `npm run build` → dist/rams.css (90ms, v4.3.3); audit harvests 49 classes from 3 pages |
| 01 | Zero Google Fonts CDN refs; self-hosted fonts | ✓ VERIFIED | grep for `fonts.googleapis|fonts.gstatic|cdn.tailwindcss` in theme/ → 0 hits; 7 woff2 files present + `@font-face` blocks + `dist/fonts` |
| 01 | DESIGN.md superseded banner | ✓ VERIFIED | lines 1–3 of DESIGN.md |
| 02 | Sheet displays every mockup component family | ✓ VERIFIED | Visual inspection of `sheet-full.png`: typography specimen (D-11), buttons, inputs, chips/badges, telemetry card, maneuver banner, checkboxes/toggle |
| 02 | Legibility specimen included (D-11) | ✓ VERIFIED | SEC-00 // LEGIBILITY section, 13 `--type-*` specimens |
| 02 | Sheet dist CSS contains zero off-token values | ✓ VERIFIED | audit exit 0 post-rebuild; components.css = 104 `var(--` refs, no literal hex (only documented 18×18 checkbox geometry, adjudication 6) |
| 03 | Basemap renders: grayscale landing, muted water/roads/labels, zero signal-orange in basemap | ✓ VERIFIED | Capture inspection + metadata; audit-style accent guard in build.mjs (`assertNoAccent`) |
| 03 | Values derived from tokens, not hand-tuned | ✓ VERIFIED | build.mjs parses tokens.css; metadata records `desaturate(tokenHex, …)` per role |
| 03 | Map labels use self-hosted Space Grotesk/Geist assets (D-10) | ⚠ VERIFIED-WITH-RECORDED-DEVIATION | See "Recorded deviation" below — hosted OpenFreeMap glyphs endpoint only serves Noto Sans (Space Grotesk/Geist 404 at build time, probed); closest hosted stack substituted, recorded in `metadata.rams-font-substitutions` with reason + revisit path. Pre-planned in 01-03 plan body, REVIEW-adjudicated clean, and inside the basemap render the user explicitly approved. |
| 04 | Audit is scripted evidence, zero off-token values (D-13) | ✓ VERIFIED | 38/38 regression tests pass (incl. T9–T12 evasion tests); exit 2 radius-drift guard |
| 04 | Static side-by-side gallery vs all 4 mockups (D-12) | ✓ VERIFIED | gallery.html, 4 rows + basemap row, all `<img>`s resolve |
| 04 | Playwright real-browser capture script committed (D-14) | ✓ VERIFIED | scripts/screenshot.mjs committed; 6/6 captures present and visually verified non-blank |
| 04 | User viewed gallery + basemap and approved | ✓ VERIFIED | Approval record, verbatim "approved" |

**Score (plan level):** 13 verified literally / 14 (1 verified-with-recorded-deviation, no goal-level gap)

### Recorded Deviation (D-10 map-label glyph stacks) — suggested formal override

Map label glyph stacks are `Noto Sans Bold / Noto Sans Regular`, not self-hosted Space Grotesk/Geist. MapLibre label glyphs must be served as pbf glyph ranges; the OpenFreeMap glyphs endpoint hosts only Noto Sans and self-hosted woff2 cannot serve glyph ranges without a glyphs route (Worker arrives in Phase 2). The substitution was pre-planned in the 01-03 plan body, is machine-recorded in `metadata.rams-font-substitutions` (intended/served/reason), was adjudicated clean by 01-REVIEW, and the user approved the rendered basemap that displays it. Rams-type *roles* are honored (bold-major / regular-minor hierarchy, muted matte labels). To formalize in the record, the developer may add to this file's frontmatter:

```yaml
overrides:
  - must_have: "Map labels use the self-hosted Space Grotesk / Geist assets (D-10)"
    reason: "OpenFreeMap glyphs endpoint hosts only Noto Sans (woff2 cannot serve pbf glyph ranges pre-Worker); closest hosted stack substituted, recorded in style metadata, and covered by the user's DSGN-02 basemap approval"
    accepted_by: "(developer)"
    accepted_at: "(timestamp)"
```

### Required Artifacts

| Artifact | Expected | Status | Details |
| -------- | -------- | ------ | ------- |
| `theme/src/tokens.css` | Token package (55 colors, 10 spacing, 9 radius all zero, 13 type vars) | ✓ VERIFIED | 176 lines; `--radius: 0px` bare key + family zeroed (CR-01 fix commit 61d15c2 present) |
| `theme/src/theme.css` | @import tokens + @font-face + scoped @source | ✓ VERIFIED | imports tokens.css + components.css; `@source not ../scripts` / `../basemap` (WR-01 fix present) |
| `theme/src/components.css` | var()-only component classes | ✓ VERIFIED | 104 var() refs, no literal hex |
| `theme/src/sheet.html` | Component sheet consuming dist/rams.css | ✓ VERIFIED | link at line 15; renders all 7 component families (screenshot inspected) |
| `theme/dist/rams.css` | Built stylesheet | ✓ VERIFIED | rebuilt this pass; radius forms token-only; no `.shadow{`/`.blur{` (WR-01) |
| `theme/basemap/build.mjs` + `liberty-rams.json` + `index.html` | Token-derived basemap + render proof | ✓ VERIFIED | derivation provenance in metadata; style JSON valid; proof page wired |
| `theme/scripts/audit.mjs` (+ test harness) | Automated D-13 audit | ✓ VERIFIED | 814 lines; scans dist, parses tokens.css allowlist, 38/38 tests |
| `theme/scripts/screenshot.mjs` | Playwright capture toolchain (D-14) | ✓ VERIFIED | WR-05 docroot guard fix present (`startsWith(THEME + sep)`) |
| `theme/gallery.html` | DSGN-02 gallery (min 80 lines) | ✓ VERIFIED | 290 lines, CDN-free |
| `theme/fonts/{geist,space-grotesk}/*.woff2` | Self-hosted typefaces | ✓ VERIFIED | 7 files |
| `.gitignore` (+ Zone scrub) | Repo hygiene | ✓ VERIFIED | 0 `*:Zone.Identifier` files remain; secrets/node_modules/dist entries present |
| `package.json` (root) | Workspace delegates | ✓ VERIFIED | build/sheet/gallery/audit/capture → theme workspace |

### Key Link Verification

| From | To | Via | Status | Details |
| ---- | -- | --- | ------ | ------- |
| theme/src/theme.css | theme/src/tokens.css | CSS @import | ✓ WIRED | line 14 |
| theme build | theme/dist/rams.css | tailwindcss CLI | ✓ WIRED | ran this pass (90ms) |
| theme/src/sheet.html | theme/dist/rams.css | `<link rel=stylesheet>` | ✓ WIRED | line 15 |
| theme/src/components.css | tokens.css | var(--color-*)/var(--spacing-*) | ✓ WIRED | 104 refs; literal scan clean |
| theme/basemap/build.mjs | theme/src/tokens.css | token parse | ✓ WIRED | metadata `derived-from`; derivation report to stdout |
| theme/basemap/index.html | liberty-rams.json | MapLibre style URL | ✓ WIRED | line 115 |
| theme/basemap/index.html | token package | getComputedStyle at runtime | ✓ WIRED | reads `--color-signal-orange`/`--color-matte-black` |
| theme/scripts/audit.mjs | tokens.css (allowlist) + dist/rams.css (scan) | default paths | ✓ WIRED | exit 0 run; exit-1/2 behavior covered by 38 tests |
| theme/scripts/screenshot.mjs | theme/screenshots/* | Playwright captures | ✓ WIRED | 6/6 captures on disk |
| theme/gallery.html | theme/screenshots/* | `<img>` rows | ✓ WIRED | 9 img elements incl. basemap row |

### Data-Flow Trace (Level 4)

| Artifact | Data Variable | Source | Produces Real Data | Status |
| -------- | ------------- | ------ | ------------------ | ------ |
| basemap/index.html | route placeholder color | `getComputedStyle(--color-signal-orange)` from dist/rams.css | Yes (token value, not hand-tuned) | ✓ FLOWING |
| liberty-rams.json | all cartography colors | tokens.css parse + desaturate() | Yes (provenance metadata per role) | ✓ FLOWING |
| sheet.html / gallery.html | styles | dist/rams.css tokens | Yes (renders verified visually) | ✓ FLOWING (static design artifacts — no dynamic data expected) |

### Behavioral Spot-Checks

| Behavior | Command | Result | Status |
| -------- | ------- | ------ | ------ |
| Build produces dist | `npm run build --workspace theme` | Done in 90ms, v4.3.3 | ✓ PASS |
| Audit sweep zero off-token | `npm run audit` | AUDIT CLEAN — 354 declarations, 0 off-token (exit 0), re-run post-rebuild | ✓ PASS |
| Theme test suite | `node theme/scripts/audit.test.mjs` | 38 PASS / 0 FAIL (first invocation hit a stale `/tmp/opencode/audit-test` symlink from the fixer's sandbox — environment artifact, not a test failure; clean re-run passed) | ✓ PASS |
| CR-01 fix: bare `rounded` var-driven | grep dist | `.rounded` → `border-radius:var(--radius)`, `--radius:0px` emitted; no `.25rem` | ✓ PASS |
| Basemap renders as Rams cartography | inspect committed `screenshots/basemap-kl.png` (real-browser capture) | Grayscale/muted map, muted labels, orange only on reserved route vector | ✓ PASS |
| Sheet renders all component families | inspect committed `screenshots/sheet-full.png` | Typography specimen + buttons + inputs + chips + card + banner + switches, zero radius | ✓ PASS |
| Renders without committed captures | serve theme/ + open gallery.html live | Not re-run live — captures committed post-fix and no worn class changed rendering between capture and now (`.rounded`/`.shadow`/`.blur` worn by zero pages) | ? SKIP (evidence already real-browser + user-approved) |

### Requirements Coverage

| Requirement | Source Plan(s) | Description | Status | Evidence |
| ----------- | -------------- | ----------- | ------ | -------- |
| DSGN-01 | 01-01, 01-02, 01-03 | All screens render from a centralized token set — no off-token values; basemap cartography follows the same tokens | ✓ SATISFIED | Audit exit 0 (scripted evidence, D-13); tokens.css single source; basemap derived per-role from tokens (D-09); component/basemap renders verified |
| DSGN-02 | 01-04 | Mockup-vs-implementation gallery reviewed for fidelity before proceeding | ✓ SATISFIED | gallery.html + Playwright captures + recorded verbatim approval ("approved", 00:51:39Z); mechanism documented for per-phase reuse |

**Orphaned requirements:** none — REQUIREMENTS.md traceability maps exactly DSGN-01/DSGN-02 to Phase 1, and both are claimed by plans. (Info: the traceability table's "Pending" checkbox text was not flipped to Complete — doc-maintenance nit, not a gap.)

### Anti-Patterns Found

| File | Line | Pattern | Severity | Impact |
| ---- | ---- | ------- | -------- | ------ |
| theme/src/theme.css | 31–34 | `@source` scans mockup markup (Tailwind Play-CDN replacement pattern) | ℹ️ Info | Intentional and deliberately narrowed (WR-01) — prose leakage tests exist (T5) |
| theme/basemap/index.html | 127 | "PLACEHOLDER ROUTE VECTOR" | ℹ️ Info | Documented scope staging — route rendering is Phase 5 per plan; reads color from tokens at runtime |
| stitch_minimalist_route_navigator/*/code.html | — | legacy inline `onclick` demo handlers | ℹ️ Info | Read-only mockups (D-06), untouched by design |
| DESIGN.md | 31–39 | hex/px restated in legacy philosophy prose | ℹ️ Info | Under explicit SUPERSEDED-FOR-SPECIFICS banner naming palette/typography as superseded; README carries zero numerics; D-05 pre-authorized keeping philosophy prose |

No TODO/FIXME/stub markers; no blocker or warning anti-patterns.

### Human Verification Required

None outstanding. The phase's blocking human checkpoint (DSGN-02 gallery + basemap review) was completed on 2026-10-22 with a recorded verbatim approval — the one item a human must decide in this phase is already decided and archived (`01-04-DSGN-02-APPROVAL.md`). Visual fidelity, real-browser rendering, and basemap appearance were all covered by that approved review, and the committed captures inspected in this verification match what was approved (no worn class changed rendering between capture time and the post-fix state).

### Gaps Summary

No goal-level gaps. All four roadmap success criteria verified against the live codebase, with the code-review blocker fix (CR-01) and all five warnings (WR-01..05) confirmed present in the artifacts and the 38-test regression suite green. One documented, pre-adjudicated, user-approved deviation exists at plan-truth level (D-10 map-label glyph stacks → closest hosted stack, machine-recorded) — it does not block the phase goal, has a recorded revisit path, and a formal override entry is suggested above if the developer wants it in the durable record.

---

_Verified: 2026-10-22T02:55:00Z_
_Verifier: OpenCode (gsd-verifier)_