{
  "doc_path": "DESIGN.md",
  "claims_checked": 14,
  "claims_passed": 14,
  "claims_failed": 0,
  "failures": [],
  "warnings": [
    {
      "line": 69,
      "claim": "Map Snapshots: Grayscale tiles with accent overlays",
      "reason": "Partially unverifiable from source. grep for 'grayscale|snapshot' across theme/src and web/src returned zero matches — no grayscale/snapshot feature is implemented. Supporting evidence exists only in prose (AGENTS.md names Maptiler for grayscale snapshots and Cloudflare R2 for storage; thread status: no Maptiler/R2 dependency in any package.json). The implemented basemap (theme/basemap/liberty-rams.json) is a low-saturation color style, not grayscale tiles. Not scored as FAIL because the claim describes a design-system intent, not implemented behavior, and DESIGN.md lines 1-2 explicitly scope the doc to 'Rams design philosophy only'."
    },
    {
      "line": 2,
      "claim": "Consult the token package (see README.md) for specific value definitions",
      "reason": "README.md exists and references theme/src/tokens.css 6 times, with sections 'Consuming the design tokens' (line 140) and 'Design system' (line 162). The doc's parenthetical '(see README.md)' is accurate in substance, though README.md has no section literally named 'token package'. Scored PASS on substance."
    }
  ],
  "verified_pass": [
    "Line 2: README.md exists and documents the token package (theme/src/tokens.css referenced 6x, 'Consuming the design tokens' section at line 140, 'Design system' section at line 162).",
    "Line 3: '55 color tokens (8 Rams brand colors + Material-style neutrals)' — grep counts exactly 55 '--color-' declarations in theme/src/tokens.css; lines 67-75 define exactly 8 Rams brand tokens (--color-signal-orange, --color-matte-black, --color-soft-beige, --color-functional-red, --color-olive-green, --color-chassis-subtle, --color-surface-dark, --color-pure-white). FIXED (previously FAIL).",
    "Line 13: '8px baseline grid' — tokens.css line 77 comment: 'Spacing: 8px baseline grid (verbatim; never recomputed — D-07)'; all --spacing-* tokens (lines 78-87) are multiples of 0.25rem/0.5rem/1rem/1.5rem/2rem/3rem.",
    "Line 21: 'Geist (body) / Space Grotesk (headings and telemetry numbers)' — tokens.css line 93 --font-sans/--font-geist = 'Geist', line 95 --font-space-grotesk = 'Space Grotesk'; headline/display tokens (lines 144-154) all use var(--font-space-grotesk). FIXED (previously claimed Helvetica/Inter, which was false).",
    "Line 21: 'no Helvetica/Inter anywhere in the design system' — grep -riE 'helvetica|\\binter\\b' across theme/src and web/src returned zero matches.",
    "Line 25: '14px body (body-md), 20px/32px headings (headline-md/lg), display-lg 48px ... exact scale lives in theme/src/tokens.css' — tokens.css: --type-body-md: 400 14px/20px (line 160), --type-headline-md: 600 20px/26px (line 152), --type-headline-lg: 700 32px/38px (line 148), --type-display-lg: 700 48px/52px (line 144). All four sizes and token names match exactly. FIXED (previously FAIL).",
    "Line 27: 'Line heights are per-token absolute leading (ratios ~1.08–1.43), defined in theme/src/tokens.css' — every --type-* token uses absolute px leading (e.g. 48px/52px, 32px/38px, 20px/26px, 14px/20px). Computed ratios span 52/48=1.08 (display-lg, the stated floor) to 20/14=1.43 (body-md, the stated ceiling). The stated range is accurate. FIXED (previously claimed 1.4x multiplier, which was false).",
    "Line 31: Signal Orange #EB8008 — tokens.css line 68 --color-signal-orange: #EB8008 (exact match).",
    "Line 33: Functional Red #ED3F1C — tokens.css line 71 --color-functional-red: #ED3F1C (exact match).",
    "Line 35: Olive Green #736B1E — tokens.css line 72 --color-olive-green: #736B1E (exact match).",
    "Line 37: Soft Beige #D9D2C6 — tokens.css line 70 --color-soft-beige: #D9D2C6 (exact match).",
    "Line 39: Matte Black #1A1A1A — tokens.css line 69 --color-matte-black: #1A1A1A (exact match).",
    "Line 43: 'Background: --color-background #FFF8F0 (warm white); Soft Beige #D9D2C6 remains a surface/accent token, not the background' — tokens.css line 64 --color-background: #fff8f0 (exact match); --color-soft-beige (#D9D2C6, line 70) is a distinct surface token. FIXED (previously claimed background was Soft Beige, which was false).",
    "Line 73: 'Report Event (target flow, not built) ... no /report command exists yet (implemented commands: /start + /mula, /help, /privacy + /privasi)' — grep for '\"(report|navigate)\"' across bot/src returned zero matches; actual bot.command() registrations are exactly start.ts:30 'start', start.ts:31 'mula', help.ts:29 'help', privacy.ts:31 'privacy', privacy.ts:32 'privasi'. Command list is complete and accurate. FIXED (previously asserted /report exists).",
    "Line 75: 'Navigation (target flow, not built) ... no /navigate command and no routing engine wired in yet (routing-adjacent stack today: MapLibre GL + OpenFreeMap tiles); validated future stack is Valhalla + Photon' — grep -i 'osrm' across bot/src, web/src, theme/src, web/basemap returned zero matches (no routing engine). web/package.json line 14 declares maplibre-gl ^6.15.0. Valhalla/Photon appear in no package.json, consistent with 'validated future stack' framing. FIXED (previously asserted /navigate + OSRM exist).",
    "Lines 57-61 icon semantics (Accident = Red triangle, Traffic = Orange car, Speed Cam = Green circle) — grep for accident/speedcam/speedtrap across the four stitch mockup code.html files returns matches in 3 files (community_incident_reporter, navigate_map_overview, telegram_live_traffic_feed); the color semantics (red/orange/green per event type) match AGENTS.md's documented event-type convention. Consistent, no contradiction found."
  ],
  "notes": "Re-verification after the fix pass: all 7 previously-failing claims are now correct. The doc was rewritten so every numeric/token claim is prefixed by an explicit pointer to theme/src/tokens.css rather than asserting standalone values, and both Interaction Flows (lines 73, 75) now lead with '(target flow, not built)' and enumerate the actually-implemented commands/stack. Grep for the old stale strings ('Helvetica', 'Inter ', '/report ', '/navigate ', 'OSRM', '1.4×', '24px title') returns matches only on lines 21, 73, 75 where they now appear inside accurate negative/clarifying statements — no false assertions remain. The remaining open item is line 69 (Map Snapshots: grayscale tiles), which is design intent with no implementation in theme/ or web/ source; it is out of scope for a philosophy-only doc per lines 1-2, and the low-saturation basemap style is not grayscale, so a future reader could still over-read this line."
}